How we judge a vault
We score on the things that actually protect you, not on polish:
- On-device encryption with a stated algorithm (AES-256), key tied to your code.
- No account required and no third-party tracking (check the App Store privacy label).
- Honest recovery (a real recovery phrase, not a reset that implies they hold your data).
- Useful extras under pressure: a duress decoy, intruder photos, disguises.
- Clear limits — a short PIN is weaker than a passphrase, and the app should say so.
The honest shortlist
Nightjar (ours): on-device AES-256-GCM, keys in the Secure Enclave, no account, no tracking, a duress decoy and intruder photos. The free plan shows one small ad at the bottom of the gallery, never tracked; Pro has no ads. Best if you want maximum on-device privacy; cross-device backup is still coming, which is its main gap today.
Vaultaire: a solid on-device encrypted vault that already ships a device-independent backup — its clearest advantage over us. Uses a 6-dot pattern rather than a passphrase, and analytics are on by default. No ads, and its App Store label shows no tracking.
KeepSafe: mature cross-platform cloud sync, which is its strength if you need your vault on Android or the web; its App Store label shows ads with tracking: data used to track you, for third-party advertising.
Private Photo Vault: popular, with a decoy and a break-in report that logs GPS; its privacy label shows ads with tracking, and photos/identifiers linked to you for advertising.
Calculator vaults: convincing disguises, but many don't state their encryption and several carry tracking labels — the disguise is only as safe as the vault behind it.
Which should you pick?
If you want everything to stay on your iPhone with no account or tracking, an on-device vault like Nightjar fits. If you specifically need cross-platform cloud sync today, KeepSafe is built for that. If cross-device backup is a must-have right now, Vaultaire ships it. Pick for your threat model — we lay out the details on each comparison page.