Compare
What a vault should do.
Capability by capability.
Most photo vaults put a PIN screen in front of files. The questions that matter are where the key check happens, what a copy of the files is worth to someone else, and what happens when you are made to open it.
Nightjar vs typical photo vaults
The capability table.
"Typical" describes the category as a whole, not any one product. Open a capability for why it matters. Rows marked with a dashed dot are built and tested but ship in a later version.
| Capability | Nightjar | Typical photo vault |
|---|---|---|
Where the key check happensIf the app checks a PIN itself, the files are only as safe as that check, and a copy of them can be attacked at leisure. Tying each guess to the phone's own chip means the phone has to be there. | Every guess goes through this iPhone's Secure Enclave, so a copy of the files can't be guessed at on another computer. | Often a PIN checked by the app itself; copied files can sometimes be opened with any file browser. |
Resistance to offline guessingMost codes are short. What stops a fast computer from trying them all is whether every try needs this phone. | The slow derivation and the Secure Enclave step are tied to this phone. | Varies; many vaults don't say. |
RecoveryA reset by email means someone other than you can open the vault. A recovery phrase means only you can, and only if you kept it. | A 12- or 24-word recovery phrase, made for every vault, free. It can also be split into 3 shares, any 2 of which restore it. | Often an email reset through an account, or nothing. |
Duress decoyThe worst case isn't a hacker; it's being made to open the app in front of someone. A believable second vault gives you something real to show. | A second code opens a separate decoy vault. Hide mode by default, destroy mode optional. | Usually a single vault behind a single PIN. |
DisguisesA calculator skin that doesn't calculate is a tell. A disguise has to be a working tool, and using it normally should never count as a wrong attempt. | Five working tools (calculator, notes, converter, timer, error screen) with matching icons. | Sometimes a calculator skin only. |
Intruder photosKnowing who tried, and when, turns a vague worry into a fact. It only helps if the photos stay on your phone. | Front-camera photo on the wrong try you choose; stays on the phone, encrypted. | Sometimes offered; storage and upload vary. |
AccountAn account is a record of you on someone's server, plus a reset path that bypasses your code. No account means neither exists. | None. No email, no phone number, no user or device id. | Frequently required for backup or sync. |
AnalyticsUsage data on by default is data about you leaving the phone before you decided anything. Off by default means you decide. | None. This version sends no statistics at all. | Often on by default, sometimes through third-party SDKs. |
Encrypted backupA backup keyed to a 6-digit PIN can be guessed by anyone who gets the backup. Keyed to a 12-word phrase, it can't be searched. | Keyed to the recovery phrase, not the PIN, in your own iCloud. Coming in a later version. | Often keyed to the same PIN, or to a cloud account the vendor controls. |
Keys between your devicesKeys that cross between phones can be recorded today and attacked later. A hybrid exchange has to be broken twice. | Keys exchanged between your devices use hybrid post-quantum (ML-KEM + X25519) encryption. Coming with device pairing in a later version. | Rarely stated. |
Hardware keyA physical key means knowing the code isn't enough. It should never replace the recovery phrase, or losing the key loses the vault. | YubiKey as a second key over NFC. Coming. More hardware keys planned. | Rare. |
Screenshot blankingThe easiest leak is a screenshot that ends up in the camera roll or a cloud album. Black by default closes it. | Screenshots and recordings of an open vault come out black by default. | Varies. |
Photo metadataLocation in a photo's metadata can say where you were. Removing it on the way in means an exported or shared copy can't give that away. | Removed on import: location, camera details, dates and other tags, from photos and videos. Only the orientation is kept; the date taken is kept inside the encrypted index. | Varies; often not stated. |
Before you trust any vault
Eight questions
worth asking.
Ask them of any photo vault, including this one. The answers are what separates a lock from a label.
- 01
Are my files actually encrypted, or just hidden behind a PIN screen?
NightjarEncrypted on your iPhone with AES-256-GCM, each vault under its own random key.
- 02
Where does the key check happen?
NightjarEvery guess goes through this iPhone's Secure Enclave, so a copy of the files is useless elsewhere.
- 03
Do I need an account, and can the maker reset my access?
NightjarNo account, no reset. Only your code or your recovery phrase opens a vault.
- 04
What happens if I'm forced to open it?
NightjarA duress code opens a decoy vault with its own contents. Nothing shows that any other vault exists.
- 05
Does it phone home by default?
NightjarNo. This version sends nothing to us at all: no account, no statistics, no uploads.
- 06
If it backs up, what is the backup key made from?
NightjarFrom the 12- or 24-word recovery phrase, never from the pattern or PIN. Backup ships in a later version.
- 07
When it shares, what does the server see?
NightjarThere is no server in the middle. Send securely makes an encrypted file on your iPhone and you send it yourself; the passphrase goes a different way.
- 08
What does it admit it can't do?
NightjarA short code is the weak point; an unlocked phone can be attacked; nothing here is audited yet. All written down on the security page.
The default alternative
Nightjar vs the album already on your iPhone.
The comparison most people actually weigh: a purpose-built vault against the Hidden album iOS gives you for free. Every line about the Hidden album is from Apple's own documentation, read 12 November 2026; where it doesn't say, the cell says so. Vaultaire and the other apps sit in the table below, each treated the same way.
| Capability | Nightjar | Apple Hidden album |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An encrypted vault app with its own keys, tied to the Secure Enclave. | An album in Photos that is hidden from the main library and locked with Face ID or Touch ID by default since iOS 16. |
| Where photos go | Stay on this iPhone, encrypted under the vault's key. | Stay in your library; with iCloud Photos on, hidden photos are hidden on your other devices too. |
| Ways to unlock | Face ID, pattern, PIN or passphrase. | Face ID, Touch ID or the device passcode. |
| Recovery | A 12- or 24-word recovery phrase per vault; it can be split into 3 shares, any 2 of which restore it. | Not needed: the device passcode is the fallback. |
| Backup key | Derived from the recovery phrase only, never from the pattern or PIN. Backup ships in a later version. | Not applicable. |
| Sending photos | Send securely: one file encrypted on the phone under your passphrase, sent by you; it never touches our server. | Not applicable. |
| Hiding the vault count | The phone looks the same with one vault or eight. | Not applicable. |
| Analytics | Off by default; opt-in and anonymous. | Not stated for this feature. |
| Ads | Free: one small ad, never tracked. Pro: no ads. | None; it is part of iOS. |
| Free limits | 3 vaults, 200 photos and 20 videos per vault; notes and files unlimited. | Free with iOS. |
Apple, iPhone, Face ID, Touch ID, iCloud and Photos are trademarks of Apple Inc. The Hidden album behaviour described is from Apple's own documentation; if something here is out of date, tell us at the address on the support page and we will correct it.
The vaults you'll meet first
Nine you'll see side by side.
The eight most-visible photo-vault listings on the App Store, plus Vaultaire. Each cell states only what the app says on its own listing or site, or the privacy labels Apple shows for it (the developer's own report, which Apple notes it hasn't verified), read on 14 November 2026; the Ads column is from the same labels, read 16 November 2026. Where it isn't stated, the cell says so — never "no". The colour is a quick read of each cell; the words are the real answer. Pic Safe, Keepsafe, SPV and PV track you for ads; Nightjar's free plan shows one small ad and never tracks you, and Pro has none.
Nightjar
✓ Most private hereThis app
- Where photos live
- On this iPhone, encrypted (AES-256-GCM); keys in the Secure Enclave.
- Account
- None.
- Decoy vault
- Duress decoy vault (Pro).
- Intruder photo
- Intruder photo on a wrong unlock (Pro).
- Tracking & analytics
- No third-party tracking; analytics off by default.
- Ads
- Free: one small ad, never tracked. Pro: no ads.
- Price
- Free; Pro $3.99/mo, $17.99/yr, $34.99 once.
Private Photo Vault – Pic Safe
Legendary Software Labs
- Where photos live
- In-app on device; encrypted copies in its Cloud Vault once you turn that on.
- Account
- Not stated (Cloud Vault uses a password you set).
- Decoy vault
- Decoy password (how it works not stated).
- Intruder photo
- Break-in report with photo + GPS.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: Usage Data tracks you; photos/videos, identifiers, purchases and usage linked to you — analytics, functionality, advertising.
- Ads
- Ads with tracking: its label lists data used to track you and third-party advertising.
- Price
- Free; upgrade and subscription, up to $39.99.
Secret Photo Vault – KeepSafe
KeepSafe Software
- Where photos live
- Device, with a cross-platform Private Cloud that syncs/backs up (up to 10,000 items).
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Not stated.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: Usage Data tracks you; usage and advertising data for third-party advertising.
- Ads
- Ads with tracking: its label lists data used to track you and third-party advertising.
- Price
- Free; Premium up to $23.99/yr.
Calculator# Hide Photos Videos
NewSoftwares.net · Disguised as a calculator
- Where photos live
- Moves photos out of your library; optional cloud backup to iCloud, Dropbox, Google Drive or OneDrive.
- Account
- Not stated (recovery via a registered email).
- Decoy vault
- Not stated (a 'disguise mode' shows a fake crash screen).
- Intruder photo
- Not stated (logs failed attempts, no photo).
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: Contact Info tracks you; email and photos/videos for app functionality.
- Ads
- Its label says it tracks you (contact info); no advertising purpose listed.
- Price
- Free with ads; $4.99/yr.
Converter – Hidden Photo Vault
Dmitry Petrov · Disguised as a converter
- Where photos live
- On the device and in your iCloud.
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Not stated.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: developer says no data is collected.
- Ads
- No ads, no tracking: its label says no data is collected.
- Price
- Free; Full Access $9.99–$19.99 once.
SPV – Secret Photo Vault
Maple Labs · Disguised as a calculator
- Where photos live
- Device only — says it 'does not keep your photos or data on any kind of server.'
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Not stated.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: identifiers, usage and diagnostics track you (third-party advertising, analytics).
- Ads
- Ads with tracking: its label lists data used to track you and third-party advertising.
- Price
- Free; from $2.99, Premium up to $39.99.
PV – Secret Photo Album
Haibin Jiao
- Where photos live
- Device storage, plus in-app and third-party cloud backup on paid tiers.
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Fake password shows a separate set of photos.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: identifiers and usage data track you across other companies' apps; email and user ID linked to you.
- Ads
- Ads with tracking: its label lists data used to track you and third-party advertising.
- Price
- Free; Pro $3.99/mo–$17.99/yr; cloud up to $79.99/yr.
Secret Photo Vault – Lock Photos
GS
- Where photos live
- Device only — 'all of your data in this app is stored only in your device.'
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Decoy accounts, each with their own decoy database.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: developer says no data is collected.
- Ads
- No ads, no tracking: its label says no data is collected.
- Price
- Free; Pro $6.99 once.
Secret Photo Album
Sunny Studio · Unlocked with a gesture pattern
- Where photos live
- Not stated.
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Not stated.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Apple label: no privacy details provided.
- Ads
- Not stated: its label gives no privacy details.
- Price
- Free; up to $7.99 once (lifetime).
Vaultaire
vaultaire.app · Unlocked with a 5×5 pattern
- Where photos live
- Encrypted on device; iCloud backup on by default (can be turned off).
- Account
- Not stated.
- Decoy vault
- Hidden vaults, but their FAQ says the count can still be estimated.
- Intruder photo
- Not stated.
- Tracking & analytics
- Their privacy page: analytics and crash diagnostics on by default; a switch turns them off.
- Ads
- No ads, no tracking; its label lists email, usage and crash data collected.
- Price
- Free: up to 3 vaults (100 photos, 10 videos total).
App names and the developers named are the property of their owners, and listing them here is comparison, not affiliation or endorsement. Privacy cells are each developer's own report — the App Store "App Privacy" labels, which Apple states it hasn't verified, or, for Vaultaire, its own privacy page. The colour is our own summary of those words for scanning. Listings change; if something here is out of date, tell us at the address on the support page and we'll correct it.
Honest limits
A short pattern or PIN is the weakest link in any vault, ours included. Choose a passphrase for anything that matters.
Not audited yet
The design is documented and tested, but has not had an independent security audit. One is planned.
Coming, not claimed
Encrypted iCloud backup and the YubiKey second key are built and tested but ship in a later version.