Compare
Nightjar vs
Vaultaire.
Both are on-device encrypted vaults, so this is the closest comparison on the page. Each cell below is only what the two apps say about themselves. Vaultaire is more transparent than most competitors, which is why a like-for-like comparison is even possible — and we call out where it leads.
| Capability | Nightjar | Vaultaire |
|---|---|---|
| Where photos live | On your iPhone, encrypted with AES-256-GCM; keys bound to the Secure Enclave. | Encrypted on the device; iCloud backup is on by default and can be turned off. (Vaultaire's pages.) |
| Unlock | Face ID, pattern, PIN or passphrase. | A pattern of at least six dots on a 5×5 grid, or the recovery phrase. |
| Recovery | A 12- or 24-word recovery phrase per vault; it can be split into 3 shares, any 2 of which restore it. | A nine-word secret phrase. |
| Cross-device backup | A device-independent backup from the recovery phrase ships in a later version. | A separate, device-independent backup key derived from the pattern — available today. |
| Sending photos | Send securely: one file encrypted on the phone under your passphrase, sent by you; it never touches our server. | Encrypted chunks in Apple's CloudKit public database; their policy notes collected share records allow offline phrase guesses. |
| Analytics | No tracking and no analytics; the free plan shows one non-personalised Google ad, Pro has none. | App analytics and crash diagnostics on by default; a Settings switch turns them off. |
| Ads and tracking | Free: one small ad, never tracked. Pro: no ads. | No ads and no tracking, per its App Store label (read 16 November 2026), which lists email, usage and crash data collected. |
Where Nightjar leads
A passphrase option (stronger than a 6-dot pattern), no analytics or ad tracking, a duress decoy and intruder photos, and a more generous free tier.
Where Vaultaire leads
Cross-device backup is live today — Vaultaire derives a device-independent backup key from your pattern, so you can restore on a new phone now. Nightjar's equivalent is built but ships later. It also shows no ads, where Nightjar's free plan shows one small one.
Product names belong to their owners; listing them here is comparison, not affiliation. Statements about Vaultaire are from its own public pages or the App Store "App Privacy" labels Apple shows (the developer's own report, which Apple notes it hasn't verified). Something out of date? Tell us on the support page.
People also ask
Questions about this comparison
- Is Nightjar a good Vaultaire alternative?
- Yes, if you want a passphrase instead of a pattern, no analytics or ad tracking, and split recovery. The one thing Vaultaire does that Nightjar doesn't yet is ship cross-device backup — that's coming in a later Nightjar version.
- What's the biggest difference between Nightjar and Vaultaire?
- Sharing. Vaultaire's own privacy page says shared vaults are uploaded as encrypted chunks to Apple's CloudKit public database, where collected records allow offline phrase guessing. Nightjar's Send securely makes one encrypted file on the phone that you send yourself, so nothing goes to a public database or to us.